... I propose to begin reprinting a series on Judaism and Christianity which first appeared in, I think, 2014. They were occasioned by my distress ... that, on instructions from Cardinal Marx, the CBCEW had joined him in a very unwholesome onslaught on the legacy of Pope Benedict.
Neither hierarchy admitted that this was precisely what they were doing. The name of Benedict/Ratzinger was not mentioned! Perhaps that is what enabled their dodgy wheeze to go through; sensible and orthodox bishops, I suspect, had no idea that they were being asked to rubbish a Prayer for the Jews which Benedict XVI had composed with his own hand only half a decade previously.
I shall continue to post as normal in the (GMT) mornings; these older reprints will, Deo volente, pop up in the (GMT) evenings.
I did begin stripping them of their threads, thinking that those who wrote comments might not now wish to be encumbered with them in repetition. But my usual inertia struck ... so, after the first piece, Tuesday December 10, those old threads will reappear. Sorry if ...
10 December 2019
9 December 2019
Rubrics, rubrics ...
So did you observe the Immaculate Conception yesterday, or are you enjoying it today?
When December 8 is a Sunday, the "EF" keeps the Festival on that Sunday (the Sunday being commemorated ... with, in the St Lawrence ORDO [have you got one yet?] Last Gospel of the Sunday). But in the Novus Ordo, the Sunday yesterday was undisturbed and the Solemnity is transferred to today, Monday. May the Theotokos, Kyria kai Despoina, amomos kai akhrantos, continue to pray for us all.
Since this Festival is not, at least in Britain, of Obligation, the Novus Ordo rule means that the great bulk of the congregation never experiences it. I think this is highly unfortunate. Even the Church of England can understand that this observance is (PHG) "appropriate to the season of Advent". And the 2005 ARCIC agreement between negotiators of the Catholic Church and of the Anglican Communion wrote "We affirm together ... that in view of her vocation to be the Mother of the Holy One, Christ's redeeming work reached 'back' in Mary to the depths of her being and to her earliest beginnings."
The idea that Sunday Masses ... especially in seasons such as Advent ... should not repeatedly be obscured by observances from the Sanctorale is, in itself and up to a point, Lord Copper, a sound principle. But if our Lady's Conception were observed on Sunday only when that Sunday was the 8th of December, this collision would happen (generally) once every six years. (There are no other Universal observances waiting to gang up on the Sundays of Advent ... I can guarantee that the Apostle S Thomas won't try it on.) Would the loss of just one Advent Sunday Mass out of 24 really be the end of the world as we know it?
[Byzantines, sensible people, allow more than one celebration to be combined in the Liturgy of a single day. The Tractarians even went so far as to preach on our Lady of Sorrows when Good Friday occurred on March 25! Few of the daft and rigid fads of the Novus Ordo are as plain silly as its grim-faced and unnatural phobia of 'Commemorations'. So Enlightenment! So Pistoia!]
Similar considerations apply to the occasions when a Festum ... such as the festival of one of the Apostles ... happens to flutter down on to one of the 'green' Sundays "per Annum" of 'Ordinary Time'. The Church of England wisely ... Yes!! ... permits either the Sunday observance or that of the Saint; decision, in a well-judged exercise of Subsidiarity, is left to the local clergy.
Cardinal Sarah once admirably attempted to bring the "EF" and "OF" calendars into line. That splendid hope was abandoned; it was indeed too ambitious given current sensitivities. But a change to the provisions in the OFalong the lines suggested here would be legislatively easy, and One Small Step in the direction of greater unity within the Roman Rite.
When December 8 is a Sunday, the "EF" keeps the Festival on that Sunday (the Sunday being commemorated ... with, in the St Lawrence ORDO [have you got one yet?] Last Gospel of the Sunday). But in the Novus Ordo, the Sunday yesterday was undisturbed and the Solemnity is transferred to today, Monday. May the Theotokos, Kyria kai Despoina, amomos kai akhrantos, continue to pray for us all.
Since this Festival is not, at least in Britain, of Obligation, the Novus Ordo rule means that the great bulk of the congregation never experiences it. I think this is highly unfortunate. Even the Church of England can understand that this observance is (PHG) "appropriate to the season of Advent". And the 2005 ARCIC agreement between negotiators of the Catholic Church and of the Anglican Communion wrote "We affirm together ... that in view of her vocation to be the Mother of the Holy One, Christ's redeeming work reached 'back' in Mary to the depths of her being and to her earliest beginnings."
The idea that Sunday Masses ... especially in seasons such as Advent ... should not repeatedly be obscured by observances from the Sanctorale is, in itself and up to a point, Lord Copper, a sound principle. But if our Lady's Conception were observed on Sunday only when that Sunday was the 8th of December, this collision would happen (generally) once every six years. (There are no other Universal observances waiting to gang up on the Sundays of Advent ... I can guarantee that the Apostle S Thomas won't try it on.) Would the loss of just one Advent Sunday Mass out of 24 really be the end of the world as we know it?
[Byzantines, sensible people, allow more than one celebration to be combined in the Liturgy of a single day. The Tractarians even went so far as to preach on our Lady of Sorrows when Good Friday occurred on March 25! Few of the daft and rigid fads of the Novus Ordo are as plain silly as its grim-faced and unnatural phobia of 'Commemorations'. So Enlightenment! So Pistoia!]
Similar considerations apply to the occasions when a Festum ... such as the festival of one of the Apostles ... happens to flutter down on to one of the 'green' Sundays "per Annum" of 'Ordinary Time'. The Church of England wisely ... Yes!! ... permits either the Sunday observance or that of the Saint; decision, in a well-judged exercise of Subsidiarity, is left to the local clergy.
Cardinal Sarah once admirably attempted to bring the "EF" and "OF" calendars into line. That splendid hope was abandoned; it was indeed too ambitious given current sensitivities. But a change to the provisions in the OFalong the lines suggested here would be legislatively easy, and One Small Step in the direction of greater unity within the Roman Rite.
8 December 2019
December 8: avoiding anathemas
How to 'reconcile' the Catholic and Orthodox attitudes to our Lady's Conception? Noble attempts have been made to reconcile the two traditions, not least under the auspices of the Ecumenical Society of the Blessed Virgin Mary, and it has become an 'ecumenical' commonplace that differences in the Latin and Greek traditions with regard to Original Sin have a fair bit to do with the 'problem'. I applaud these attempts, but instead of picking around in the gloom of 'problems' (or, as we nowadays call them, 'issues'), I want, briefly, to look at ... er ... well, I want to enjoy ... the underlying theological convergence between the Festival we Catholics celebrate today, and the meaning of a festival which has a low profile in the Roman Calendar but is right up with the front-runners in the Byzantine Calendar: that of our Lady's Presentation in the Temple (Nov 21).
What unites East and West in each case is this: our Lady is situated, contemplated, in a prelapsarian context, although the Western Definition happily safeguards the important fact that it is intuitu meritorum Filii sui, through the redemptive work of the Cross, that her status as the New Eve is hers.. In other words, Back to Eden ... or, perhaps, full throttle ahead to Eden! For us Latin Catholics, she is the new Eve and as immaculate as the first Eve was before her Fall. The Obedience of the New Eve leads to the Obedience of the Second Adam, just as the disobedience of the First Eve led to the Fall of the First Adam, the felix culpa. And, for the great Byzantine Doctor S Gregory Palamas, Mary, after she was presented in the Temple by SS Anne and Joachim, was fed there with "mystic food by the care of the angels, food which Adam had not tasted: because, if he had, he would not have fallen from life". (Byzantine iconography shows the Angels bringing the infant Theotokos this Food from the paradisal Tree of Life.) Palamas goes on to argue that "this immaculate woman" did not logically need to die; although briefly she did so before her Assumption.
So West and East unite in seeing our Lady as the Paradisal Mother of the New Adam, Queen of Eden, Queen of Heaven, the Immaculate one.
Those, of course, who deny the Immaculate Conception fall under the anathema implied by Blessed Pius IX's definition of 1854. But amusingly, those who deny the Presentation fall under the anathemas of the fourteenth century 'Palamite' Councils, damning those who say that "the Immaculate One, the Theometer ... did not enter into the Holy of Holies".
Steer clear of Anathemas!
What unites East and West in each case is this: our Lady is situated, contemplated, in a prelapsarian context, although the Western Definition happily safeguards the important fact that it is intuitu meritorum Filii sui, through the redemptive work of the Cross, that her status as the New Eve is hers.. In other words, Back to Eden ... or, perhaps, full throttle ahead to Eden! For us Latin Catholics, she is the new Eve and as immaculate as the first Eve was before her Fall. The Obedience of the New Eve leads to the Obedience of the Second Adam, just as the disobedience of the First Eve led to the Fall of the First Adam, the felix culpa. And, for the great Byzantine Doctor S Gregory Palamas, Mary, after she was presented in the Temple by SS Anne and Joachim, was fed there with "mystic food by the care of the angels, food which Adam had not tasted: because, if he had, he would not have fallen from life". (Byzantine iconography shows the Angels bringing the infant Theotokos this Food from the paradisal Tree of Life.) Palamas goes on to argue that "this immaculate woman" did not logically need to die; although briefly she did so before her Assumption.
So West and East unite in seeing our Lady as the Paradisal Mother of the New Adam, Queen of Eden, Queen of Heaven, the Immaculate one.
Those, of course, who deny the Immaculate Conception fall under the anathema implied by Blessed Pius IX's definition of 1854. But amusingly, those who deny the Presentation fall under the anathemas of the fourteenth century 'Palamite' Councils, damning those who say that "the Immaculate One, the Theometer ... did not enter into the Holy of Holies".
Steer clear of Anathemas!
7 December 2019
APPEAL
Did John Mirk give an account of an appearance of S Michael at St Michael's Mount in Cornwall? I would be grateful if anyone could help with a link ... if he did ...
Mindgames (4) Spot the Latin Howler
Today, I offer you a real de luxe corker: part of the homily attached to the propers for Padre Pio. Presumably, the Howler-wallah is the poor fellow who was tasked with translating a text from the pen of the Saint from Italian into Latin (or did S Pius himself preach/write in this ungrammatical Latin?). In what follows, no fewer than three words (I think I would actually argue, five) have fullest Megahowler status. As the young people who wait upon us in restaurants nowadays so cheerfully say, Enjoy!!!!
Anima quaeque ad aeternam destinata gloriam se optime lapis ad aedificium aeternum erigendum constituta definire potest. Structori aedem erigendum quaerenti optime primum lapides ipsam exstructuras expolire oportet.
You will also have noticed some oddish constructions ('aedem erigendum quaerenti'?) .
Elsewhere in the Homily, our friend writes 'expoliatione' ('denuding', give or take an s) where he means 'expolitione' (polishing) and (a regular mistake when Eye Ties type Latin) "cum Sancto Spirito".
Anima quaeque ad aeternam destinata gloriam se optime lapis ad aedificium aeternum erigendum constituta definire potest. Structori aedem erigendum quaerenti optime primum lapides ipsam exstructuras expolire oportet.
You will also have noticed some oddish constructions ('aedem erigendum quaerenti'?) .
Elsewhere in the Homily, our friend writes 'expoliatione' ('denuding', give or take an s) where he means 'expolitione' (polishing) and (a regular mistake when Eye Ties type Latin) "cum Sancto Spirito".
5 December 2019
My comments on your comments.
Comments on comments on Fake News.
(1) I share the dislike expressed in one comment towards the habit of calling every Anglican cleric/clergyman/priest/clerk in Holy Orders a "Vicar". I have never been a Vicar; whenever people have accused me of being or having been a Vicar I have always stoutly denied it. When I have been wearing a clerical collar, this has puzzled them. I never enlighten them: let them find it all out for themselves. We must not spoonfeed the laity.
The suggestion, on the other hand, that Anglican clergy would be horrified to be described as 'priests' can only be true of a tiny minority of violent Calvinists. They, poor dears, must have been horrified to hear themselves being described as "priests in the Church of God" when their Bishop laid his hands upon them! Every time they look at their Letters of Orders, they must tremble with revulsion!! The rubrics of the Prayer Book must be a continual source of conscientious agony!!!
(2) Prayers for the Conversion of the Jews in the Liturgia Horarum: I have dealt very fully with this several times before. The current but erroneous dogma (i.e. that we may not envisage or pray for their conversion) is subsequent to the Liturgia Horarum of 1971, at least at the CDW and within the Anglosphere (the 1985 Editio did not change this text). The most striking example is in LH Vespers on Easter Day itself ... repeated on the Third and Fifth Sundays in Eastertide (both in the Latin and in the English).
Would it be helpful if I retrieved my old extensive posts on this subject and republished them?
(3) The occupant of the See of Westminster is most certainly not Head of the Catholic Church in this country. Here again, I have dealt with this very fully on several occasions.
Again I ask: would it be helpful if I retrieved and reissued those articles?
Interestingly, when Vincent Nichols appeared before the Independent Inquiry on sexual abuse just a few weeks ago, he clarified to the tribunal his own position as merely the elected Chairman of the Episcopal Conference, and very firmly, very explicitly, denied being 'Head' of the Catholic Church in this country. He seemed particularly anxious to make this accurately understood. (You can watch the video.)
Nevertheless, some Catholic bishops do refer respectfully to him as "the Cardinal"; and I know of a recent example where he has even been assured of "loyalty". There may indeed be some danger of his being taken too seriously, through a sort of de facto and informal Fuehrerprinzip. But that is not his fault! Nor is it mine!! I support him in this!!! C'mon! Everybody behind Vin! Repeat after me: He is not Head of the Church in this land!
Finally, on my own account, (4), a question of my own which I have posed many times before.
Who knew what about Kieran Conry before he was consecrated Bishop?
(1) I share the dislike expressed in one comment towards the habit of calling every Anglican cleric/clergyman/priest/clerk in Holy Orders a "Vicar". I have never been a Vicar; whenever people have accused me of being or having been a Vicar I have always stoutly denied it. When I have been wearing a clerical collar, this has puzzled them. I never enlighten them: let them find it all out for themselves. We must not spoonfeed the laity.
The suggestion, on the other hand, that Anglican clergy would be horrified to be described as 'priests' can only be true of a tiny minority of violent Calvinists. They, poor dears, must have been horrified to hear themselves being described as "priests in the Church of God" when their Bishop laid his hands upon them! Every time they look at their Letters of Orders, they must tremble with revulsion!! The rubrics of the Prayer Book must be a continual source of conscientious agony!!!
(2) Prayers for the Conversion of the Jews in the Liturgia Horarum: I have dealt very fully with this several times before. The current but erroneous dogma (i.e. that we may not envisage or pray for their conversion) is subsequent to the Liturgia Horarum of 1971, at least at the CDW and within the Anglosphere (the 1985 Editio did not change this text). The most striking example is in LH Vespers on Easter Day itself ... repeated on the Third and Fifth Sundays in Eastertide (both in the Latin and in the English).
Would it be helpful if I retrieved my old extensive posts on this subject and republished them?
(3) The occupant of the See of Westminster is most certainly not Head of the Catholic Church in this country. Here again, I have dealt with this very fully on several occasions.
Again I ask: would it be helpful if I retrieved and reissued those articles?
Interestingly, when Vincent Nichols appeared before the Independent Inquiry on sexual abuse just a few weeks ago, he clarified to the tribunal his own position as merely the elected Chairman of the Episcopal Conference, and very firmly, very explicitly, denied being 'Head' of the Catholic Church in this country. He seemed particularly anxious to make this accurately understood. (You can watch the video.)
Nevertheless, some Catholic bishops do refer respectfully to him as "the Cardinal"; and I know of a recent example where he has even been assured of "loyalty". There may indeed be some danger of his being taken too seriously, through a sort of de facto and informal Fuehrerprinzip. But that is not his fault! Nor is it mine!! I support him in this!!! C'mon! Everybody behind Vin! Repeat after me: He is not Head of the Church in this land!
Finally, on my own account, (4), a question of my own which I have posed many times before.
Who knew what about Kieran Conry before he was consecrated Bishop?
4 December 2019
Ultrasuperueberhyperpapalism by the Bergoglian bucketful
This I saw recently in an ultrapapalist website:
"Pope Francis has said that we are currently in a change of epochs or eras and not just experiencing a period of change. It is a time of a colossal paradigm shift. One stone will not be left upon another. Many of the sacred institutions and unique religious symbols that Catholics have clung to and defended for so long -- even for ceturies -- may no longer be left standing in this change of epochs. Those that are not essential will need to be changed or discarded. Francis is trying to discern how and to what extent we need to do this. But he is facing resistance. Some of this is being manifested through attacks against his integrity as a disciple and faith leader."
I pass over (praetereo!) the snide nastinesses ("clung to" etc.); if there has been a change of eras, one of its most striking features has been the triumph of a culture of snide nastiness on the lips of the Pontiff and his cronies.
I just want to know where this model of the papacy ... the Pontiff as the Mighty Changer of Epochs ... the Great Caster Down of Stones ... the August Discerner of Discardable Dogmas ... Colossal Shifter of Paradigms ... is to be found in, or can be justified from, the teachings of Vatican I (or Vatican II) upon the Petrine Ministry.
It is certainly not to be found in the teaching of the most recent significant theologian to be canonised, S John Henry Newman, Patron of the Jurisdiction to which I have the honour to belong. He saw the Roman Church as a remora, obstacle, against innovation. Earlier writers, earlier popes, earlier councils, took the same view.
PF thinks he is 'ecumenical', because he kisses oriental hierarchs with beards and swedish episcopussies without them. Does he seriously think that, if he explained frankly to his supposed chums the (claimed) extent of his personal power to refashion the Christian Faith at will, they would react with anything other than horrified alarm?
I subscribed formally to the teaching of Vatican I some sixty years ago, on 28 April 1959, when I signed up to the Catholic League. I have no intention of falling away now from this divinely-imparted Faith. I repudiate ex animo any concept of the Papacy which could afford plausibility to the passage I have quoted above.
"Pope Francis has said that we are currently in a change of epochs or eras and not just experiencing a period of change. It is a time of a colossal paradigm shift. One stone will not be left upon another. Many of the sacred institutions and unique religious symbols that Catholics have clung to and defended for so long -- even for ceturies -- may no longer be left standing in this change of epochs. Those that are not essential will need to be changed or discarded. Francis is trying to discern how and to what extent we need to do this. But he is facing resistance. Some of this is being manifested through attacks against his integrity as a disciple and faith leader."
I pass over (praetereo!) the snide nastinesses ("clung to" etc.); if there has been a change of eras, one of its most striking features has been the triumph of a culture of snide nastiness on the lips of the Pontiff and his cronies.
I just want to know where this model of the papacy ... the Pontiff as the Mighty Changer of Epochs ... the Great Caster Down of Stones ... the August Discerner of Discardable Dogmas ... Colossal Shifter of Paradigms ... is to be found in, or can be justified from, the teachings of Vatican I (or Vatican II) upon the Petrine Ministry.
It is certainly not to be found in the teaching of the most recent significant theologian to be canonised, S John Henry Newman, Patron of the Jurisdiction to which I have the honour to belong. He saw the Roman Church as a remora, obstacle, against innovation. Earlier writers, earlier popes, earlier councils, took the same view.
PF thinks he is 'ecumenical', because he kisses oriental hierarchs with beards and swedish episcopussies without them. Does he seriously think that, if he explained frankly to his supposed chums the (claimed) extent of his personal power to refashion the Christian Faith at will, they would react with anything other than horrified alarm?
I subscribed formally to the teaching of Vatican I some sixty years ago, on 28 April 1959, when I signed up to the Catholic League. I have no intention of falling away now from this divinely-imparted Faith. I repudiate ex animo any concept of the Papacy which could afford plausibility to the passage I have quoted above.
3 December 2019
Fake News
"[Pope Benedict] managed to offend the worldwide Jewish community. First he restored to general use an ancient prayer calling on God to rescue the Jews from their 'blindness' by 'acknowledging Christ' ...".
Thus, not long ago, wrote one Richard Morrison in The Times in a 'book teview'.
He may be the same person as the Richard Morrison who is Music Critic in that newspaper.
I have no competence in the fiield of Music, so I would refrain from pontificating about his competence as a musician. If I did express a view that, as a musician, Morrison is totally Cra**, my opinion would be completely worthless.
No such bashful shyness holds back this Morrison when he strays beyond areas in which he may, for all I know, be competent.
Incredible, isn't it? As readers will all know, the ancient Good Friday Prayer for the Jews was replaced in the changes which followed Vatican II.
That left it still in use only in that comparatively tiny number of communities which still used the liturgy in Latin as it had been before the Council. These groups continued to use the prayer, in a slightly toned down form, on this one day in the year.
What Pope Benedict did was not "to restore... [the] ancient prayer". Quite the opposite. He banned it.
Yes; he removed it from the liturgy.
Then he replaced it with a prayer which he composed himself.
That new prayer of his is still used, but only by the tiny minority of Catholics who use the old Latin Liturgy.
"He restored to general use an ancient prayer". He did nothing of the sort. He replaced it. And his replacement prayer is not "in general use". The prayer "in general use", that is, among those who pray in the vernacular, is still the prayer which was introduced after the Council.
Newspapers generally, I believe, employ specialist writers when it comes to, say, Music or Economics or Astrophysics or Cricket.
But when it comes to "Religion",any old ignoramus dragged in off the street is good enough specialist competence is regarded as unnecessary.
Thus, not long ago, wrote one Richard Morrison in The Times in a 'book teview'.
He may be the same person as the Richard Morrison who is Music Critic in that newspaper.
I have no competence in the fiield of Music, so I would refrain from pontificating about his competence as a musician. If I did express a view that, as a musician, Morrison is totally Cra**, my opinion would be completely worthless.
No such bashful shyness holds back this Morrison when he strays beyond areas in which he may, for all I know, be competent.
Incredible, isn't it? As readers will all know, the ancient Good Friday Prayer for the Jews was replaced in the changes which followed Vatican II.
That left it still in use only in that comparatively tiny number of communities which still used the liturgy in Latin as it had been before the Council. These groups continued to use the prayer, in a slightly toned down form, on this one day in the year.
What Pope Benedict did was not "to restore... [the] ancient prayer". Quite the opposite. He banned it.
Yes; he removed it from the liturgy.
Then he replaced it with a prayer which he composed himself.
That new prayer of his is still used, but only by the tiny minority of Catholics who use the old Latin Liturgy.
"He restored to general use an ancient prayer". He did nothing of the sort. He replaced it. And his replacement prayer is not "in general use". The prayer "in general use", that is, among those who pray in the vernacular, is still the prayer which was introduced after the Council.
Newspapers generally, I believe, employ specialist writers when it comes to, say, Music or Economics or Astrophysics or Cricket.
But when it comes to "Religion",
2 December 2019
KCMG?
I gather we are due to have a visit from Trump.
And we have just had a terrorist incident in London involving loss of life.
On a previous such occasion, Trump seized the opportunity gleefully to continue his spat with the Mayor of London.
I think he should be decorated.
Perhaps there is a vacancy in whatever distinguished Order of Knighthood they gave the late Ceauscescu.
Was it a Kindly Call Me God?
And we have just had a terrorist incident in London involving loss of life.
On a previous such occasion, Trump seized the opportunity gleefully to continue his spat with the Mayor of London.
I think he should be decorated.
Perhaps there is a vacancy in whatever distinguished Order of Knighthood they gave the late Ceauscescu.
Was it a Kindly Call Me God?
Deeply wailing
I expect that the superb Wesleyan hymn Lo! He comes with clouds descending is now being wheeled out for Advent in Anglican churches ... indeed, it is a fine hymn; magnificently superior to a lot of what one gets in Novus Ordo Catholic churches.
The recent C of E Report on relations between Christians and Jews enters a caveat. Might it encourage anti-semitism?
Those who set at nought and sold him,
Pierced and nailed him to the tree,
Deeply wailing
Shall the true Messiah see.
I can set these fears at rest.
Anglicans and Protestants pay no attention whatsoever to the words of hymns. It's the tunes they like. That is why they often nag their clergy for services along the lines of Hymns of Praise rather than that boring Holy Communion Service. It is why they talk about their 'favourite hymns'.
I bet there isn't a worshipper in England who would ever have thiught that the 'Deep Wailing' is scheduled to be done by Jews.
I advise the C of E to watch it. You''ll get into no end of trouble if you start assuming that your pew-fodder pays any attention to, or might be influenced by, the actual words of all your finest hymns.
That's not what Post-Christian Folk Protestantism is all about!
The recent C of E Report on relations between Christians and Jews enters a caveat. Might it encourage anti-semitism?
Those who set at nought and sold him,
Pierced and nailed him to the tree,
Deeply wailing
Shall the true Messiah see.
I can set these fears at rest.
Anglicans and Protestants pay no attention whatsoever to the words of hymns. It's the tunes they like. That is why they often nag their clergy for services along the lines of Hymns of Praise rather than that boring Holy Communion Service. It is why they talk about their 'favourite hymns'.
I bet there isn't a worshipper in England who would ever have thiught that the 'Deep Wailing' is scheduled to be done by Jews.
I advise the C of E to watch it. You''ll get into no end of trouble if you start assuming that your pew-fodder pays any attention to, or might be influenced by, the actual words of all your finest hymns.
That's not what Post-Christian Folk Protestantism is all about!
1 December 2019
Reparation
Is this Advent the proper occasion for us to offer Masses and Rosaries in reparation for all the offences done to the Divine Majesty since the demolition of the old liturgical culture, fifty years ago?
Come and save us!
Here is an extract from a very fine Advent homily given by Pope Benedict XVI in 2008:
"The cry of hope of Advent expresses all the gravity of our condition, our extreme need for salvation. Which is to say that we await the Lord not as some beautiful decoration to a world already saved, but as the only way of liberation from mortal danger."
What was so noteworthy about this is that it represented a turning away from the semi-Pelagianism which characterised the post-Conciliar selection of Advent Sunday collects; Benedict instead turned back to the authentic tones of the Sunday collects which they replaced. Three of these (and notice also the Ember Masses) did a moderately unusual thing in the Roman Corpus of collects: they began with an imperative verb for their first word. This, in turn, was taken from psalm 79/80: 'Excita potentiam tuam et veni ut salvos facias nos' (Coverdale: Stir up thy strength and come and help us); a cry from Israel to her God to come and save His vineyard; a psalm full of a sense of dereliction and of pressing supplication. This urgent prayer became the starting point of three of the Advent Sunday collects in the old rite (as well as of the Collect of the Sunday Next Before Advent). Here is the translation which the good old English Missal gives for the collect of Advent I:
Stir up, we beseech thee, O Lord, thy power and come: that by thy protection we may be found worthy to be set free from the dangers of our sins which beset us; and to be saved by thy deliverance.
Compare this with (my translation) the OF collect:
Grant, we beseech thee, almighty God, this will unto thy faithful people, that, running with good works to meet thy Christ as he comes, they may be set at his right hand and be worthy to hold fast the kingdom of heaven.
There is absolutely nothing heretical or even ill-judged in itself about this; it appears in the Gelasian Sacramentary as a postcommunion. And the Stir up prayer has, indeed, survived into the OF as a ferial collect on (just one) weekday. But in the old days, Stir up was heard by all the worshipping community because it was a Sunday collect; moreover, it was repeated on every vacant feria throughout its week.
Lorenzo Bianchi says this about the newer selection of Sunday Collects in the post-Conciliar Missal: 'A Pelagian turn of thought becomes apparent: which does not show itself in a failure to speak about grace, but in the way it is separated from a realistic consideration of the human condition; and the manner in which the grace of Jesus Christ is made into an optional extra: just an unnecessary ornament ... [in the Advent Sundays and Christmas collects of] the new Missal ... sin does not appear, or even expressions explicitly linked with this concept ... [instead] we find phrases which, making no mention of the fragility of the human condition, tend to bring to the fore the aspect of man's commitment'. In the old Stir up series of collects, Bianchi goes on, 'a far more continual and pressing use of the imperative is found ... in place of these imperatives, in Paul VI's Missal the final or consecutive subjunctive prevails. Thus, even on the level of syntax, we pass from the cry of petition, from a dynamic of pure petition, to a basically descriptive phraseology'.
"The cry of hope of Advent expresses all the gravity of our condition, our extreme need for salvation. Which is to say that we await the Lord not as some beautiful decoration to a world already saved, but as the only way of liberation from mortal danger."
What was so noteworthy about this is that it represented a turning away from the semi-Pelagianism which characterised the post-Conciliar selection of Advent Sunday collects; Benedict instead turned back to the authentic tones of the Sunday collects which they replaced. Three of these (and notice also the Ember Masses) did a moderately unusual thing in the Roman Corpus of collects: they began with an imperative verb for their first word. This, in turn, was taken from psalm 79/80: 'Excita potentiam tuam et veni ut salvos facias nos' (Coverdale: Stir up thy strength and come and help us); a cry from Israel to her God to come and save His vineyard; a psalm full of a sense of dereliction and of pressing supplication. This urgent prayer became the starting point of three of the Advent Sunday collects in the old rite (as well as of the Collect of the Sunday Next Before Advent). Here is the translation which the good old English Missal gives for the collect of Advent I:
Stir up, we beseech thee, O Lord, thy power and come: that by thy protection we may be found worthy to be set free from the dangers of our sins which beset us; and to be saved by thy deliverance.
Compare this with (my translation) the OF collect:
Grant, we beseech thee, almighty God, this will unto thy faithful people, that, running with good works to meet thy Christ as he comes, they may be set at his right hand and be worthy to hold fast the kingdom of heaven.
There is absolutely nothing heretical or even ill-judged in itself about this; it appears in the Gelasian Sacramentary as a postcommunion. And the Stir up prayer has, indeed, survived into the OF as a ferial collect on (just one) weekday. But in the old days, Stir up was heard by all the worshipping community because it was a Sunday collect; moreover, it was repeated on every vacant feria throughout its week.
Lorenzo Bianchi says this about the newer selection of Sunday Collects in the post-Conciliar Missal: 'A Pelagian turn of thought becomes apparent: which does not show itself in a failure to speak about grace, but in the way it is separated from a realistic consideration of the human condition; and the manner in which the grace of Jesus Christ is made into an optional extra: just an unnecessary ornament ... [in the Advent Sundays and Christmas collects of] the new Missal ... sin does not appear, or even expressions explicitly linked with this concept ... [instead] we find phrases which, making no mention of the fragility of the human condition, tend to bring to the fore the aspect of man's commitment'. In the old Stir up series of collects, Bianchi goes on, 'a far more continual and pressing use of the imperative is found ... in place of these imperatives, in Paul VI's Missal the final or consecutive subjunctive prevails. Thus, even on the level of syntax, we pass from the cry of petition, from a dynamic of pure petition, to a basically descriptive phraseology'.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)